Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Why the Canon Leans Left: Art, Empathy and the Politics of the New

From Romanticism to modernism, the movements that fill the museums began as mutinies. The conservative claim on “Western civilization” is a custody dispute, and the paperwork is thin.

Spend an afternoon among the people who say “Western civilization” with a capital W and a faint tremor of the lip, and the ethnographer’s notebook fills fast. The rites are consistent. A marble bust appears on the banner, always white, always pristine, a detail that would have baffled the Greeks, who painted their statues in oranges and cyans that would embarrass a roadside motel. The incantation “Judeo-Christian” is chanted by men who would struggle to name three minor prophets. The sacred ancestors (Plato, Michelangelo, Mozart) are summoned the way a tavern summons a dead regular: loudly, and with the confident assumption that he would have wanted the round bought for everyone.

Now audit the ancestors. Socrates, patriarch of the whole enterprise, was executed by his own city for corrupting the young and doubting the gods. Galileo spent his last years under house arrest for basically telling the governing authority of the time to get stuffed. Mozart set to music a comedy that the Habsburg censors had banned in Vienna for sneering at aristocrats. The family portrait over the rally’s mantelpiece shows a long line of people who spent their careers being told to sit down.

That pattern is the subject here, and it fits in one sentence. The movements that built the Western canon were, with a handful of famous exceptions, insurrections against whatever the previous generation had declared permanent, and insurrection against permanence has always sat on the left side of the room. The conservative claim on Western civilization is a custody dispute in which one parent skipped every school play and now demands the trophies.

A Syllabus Written Under Army Orders

In 1917 the United States Army commissioned Columbia University to build a course explaining to student soldiers why the war was worth the trouble of dying in. The course was called War Issues. Two years later, renamed and sent back into peacetime, it became the seed of Columbia’s Core Curriculum, and the template for what American undergraduates would thereafter know as Western Civ. A procurement order, in other words. The unbroken marble corridor from Athens to the Heritage Foundation was assembled into a syllabus by professors on a War Department contract.

The philosopher Kwame Anthony Appiah has pointed out that the phrase “Western culture” is younger than the phonograph. It hardened into common sense around the First World War, which happens to be when the Army went shopping for a syllabus.

A brand, then, with an origin story as flattering as any energy drink’s: invented recently, marketed to the young, sold on the promise of ancient provenance. Brands attract trademark disputes. One observes how the claimants behave when asked for receipts.

Four Revolts and a Red Waistcoat

Think of the Western canon as a cliff face. Slice it open and the strata show: each band a revolt, pressed flat by centuries of weight into something that looks, to the passing tourist, like the natural order of the earth. The tourist reads the cliff as permanence. The geologist reads it as a record of violence. Bedrock is lava that stopped being interesting.

Begin with Romanticism, the fault line under everything that came after. Wordsworth’s preface to Lyrical Ballads proposed that poetry should speak in the language of ordinary working people, an idea that landed in Georgian drawing rooms roughly the way a union organizer lands at a golf club. Shelley answered the cavalry charge at Peterloo in 1819 with The Mask of Anarchy, which publishers judged too dangerous to print until 1832. Byron died of fever at Missolonghi in 1824, in service of Greek independence, a romantic death in the sense that an actuary would have laughed.

Then Paris, 1830. Hugo’s Hernani opened at the Comédie-Française and the premiere turned into a brawl. The old guard held the expensive seats. Hugo’s claque, Théophile Gautier among them, arrived in long hair and a red waistcoat, dressed as a carnival that had been dropped from a height. The two camps fought for the length of the run. One imagines the wigs.

Then 1863. The official Salon jury rejected so many paintings that Napoleon III, of all people, ordered the refused works hung in a separate show. Among them sat Manet’s picnic, a nude woman lunching beside clothed men and regarding the viewer with the composure of someone waiting for a bus. Crowds came to jeer. The rejects now hang in the great museums, and the jurors survive in footnotes explaining who snubbed whom.

Who tore up the unities of the classical stage? Who hung life-size peasants on a canvas the size of a barn wall and called it history painting? Who sent a naked picnicker to stare down an emperor? Radicals, bohemians, dissidents and the chronically underemployed. The canon is the building where their rejection slips hang framed.

The Painter and the Column

Courbet painted that barn-wall funeral, and he shows the arrangement better than anyone because he followed it to the end. In 1871 he sat on the Paris Commune’s commission for protecting artworks and urged that the Vendôme Column, Napoleon’s bronze victory pillar, come down as an imperial emblem. The Commune decided to topple it outright, and on May 16 a jubilant crowd did, with ropes and winches. When the Commune fell, the government jailed Courbet for six months and later presented him with the bill for rebuilding the column, reportedly north of 300,000 francs (A wee bit shy of two-million USD in today’s money, by the best of my reckoning). He fled to Switzerland and died there in 1877 with the invoice outstanding.

Here, in one biography, are both parents of the Western canon: a painter whose work now anchors the Musée d’Orsay, and a fugitive whose crime was demolishing state-approved bronze.

The twentieth century ran the experiment at scale. André Breton joined the French Communist Party in 1927 and was expelled six years later for insubordination, a career arc surrealism took as a compliment. Picasso joined in 1944, held the card until he died, and lent the Party’s peace congress a dove.

Yes, Pound Existed

Yes. Modernism had a right wing, and it was gifted and vile in installments. Ezra Pound spent the Second World War broadcasting for Mussolini’s radio. Filippo Marinetti signed up with the Fascists early and stayed late. Wyndham Lewis wrote a book admiring Hitler. T. S. Eliot cataloged himself as a classicist in literature, a royalist in politics and an Anglo-Catholic in religion, which is the most articulate bid for custody the canon has ever received.

The distinction deserves precision, because the false equivalence is the comfortable one. Pound and Marinetti were rebels against the liberal bourgeois order. Marinetti’s founding manifesto of 1909 volunteered to wreck the museums and libraries, and his comrades wanted the inheritance torched with themselves enthroned in the ashes. Their politics ran right; their aesthetics ran toward arson. And watch what happens the moment fascism acquires a government. The Futurists’ taste for novelty expires on contact with power, and the commissions go to columns.

The left holds no cleaner record. Moscow decreed Socialist Realism in 1934, and the avant-garde that had decorated the Revolution was retrained or buried. Vsevolod Meyerhold, whose theater had served as the Revolution’s laboratory, was shot in 1940. Both dictatorships landed on the same house style: heroic figures, clean muscles, a sheaf of wheat.

Power is a conservative by profession. Whoever holds the keys starts conserving within eighteen months, whatever the flag. The avant-garde leans left because dissent lives there, and when the left takes the keys, the avant-garde’s quarrel with it resumes, usually in a worse climate. The vocabulary keeps the score. “Left” began as a seating chart: in 1789 the French deputies who wanted to rearrange the kingdom sat to one side of the president, and the defenders of royal prerogative sat to the other.

Why the Western Canon Leans Left

Now the numbers. A meta-analysis of 232 samples and 575,691 respondents found that openness to experience, the trait defined by appetite for novelty, creativity and unconventionality, correlates negatively with conservatism at r = −.145. That is modest. It is also nearly twice the strength of the next-best personality predictor of ideology, it runs stronger in wealthy Western democracies than elsewhere, and the same chapter’s review of longitudinal work finds little evidence of a causal link. Call it a nudge. A nudge applied across centuries of sorting, who picks up the brush and who takes the bank job, adds up to a cliff.

The sorting covers half of it. A canon is a filter run backward: history keeps the work that was refused first, because refusal is how work gets noticed. Anyone aiming for the Western canon needs an incumbent to defy, and incumbents are conservative by job description.

Then comes the part the working title promised: empathy. Art’s raw material is other people’s insides. Wordsworth’s leech-gatherer, Goya’s civilians facing the firing squad, Courbet’s gravediggers, Dickens’ workhouse orphans: the traffic of the canon runs steadily toward people the previous generation had cropped out of the picture. Widening the frame is an act of imagination, and the decorators of the old frame call it politics. Every expansion of whom art may look at is a political act, and people who announce a distaste for politics in art generally mean a distaste for new faces in it.

The modern left likes to cite this inheritance while hanging approved posters in donor lobbies, which sits a long way from pulling down a column. The record belongs to the people who took the risk.

The Custody Hearing

In July 1937 the Reich opened two exhibitions in Munich a day apart. The Great German Art Exhibition showed the approved: heroic bodies, honest peasants, landscapes pruned for ideology. A short walk away, the Degenerate Art show hung confiscated modernists badly, on purpose, under insulting captions. More than two million people visited the degenerate show; fewer than 500,000 saw the approved one. A regime with the full apparatus of the state behind it produced history’s most effective advertisement for modern art, and failed, hilariously, to intend it.

Eighty-eight years later the instinct carries an executive order number. Executive Order 14344, signed August 28, 2025, declares classical and traditional architecture the preferred style for federal buildings and sets it as the default in the capital. A federal government may build in whatever style it likes, and the Capitol’s columns are lovely. The telling part is the reflex: whenever the state chooses an official style, it reaches backward. The order invokes Washington and Jefferson, and Jefferson lifted the Virginia Capitol from a Roman temple in Nîmes, architectural shoplifting from a world he was busy leaving. The colonnade the order prefers began as a manifesto against the powdered excess of kings.

Surely classical beauty belongs to everybody? It does. Beauty belongs to the species, and a press release claiming it for one party is fencing the sea.

So convene the hearing and examine the record. One parent produces receipts: a red waistcoat, a refused painting, a bill for a bronze column. The other produces a banner. Western civilization’s loudest defenders love the canon the way pigeons love a statue: devotedly, from above, and with measurable impact.

Go back to the Greeks and their orange gods. Pigment fades under centuries of weather, and later admirers looked at the bleached remainder and declared the white to be the ideal. Taste canonized the damage. The original was gaudy and loud, built to be argued over on the temple steps. Whoever wants that inheritance should check under the fingernails of the rebels, where the paint is still wet.


Further Reading:

Have any thoughts?

Share your reaction or leave a quick response — we’d love to hear what you think!

Leave a Comment

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.

Home Arts & Humanities Why the Canon Leans Left: Art, Empathy and the Politics of the New